Back to Caiaphas. Role size is interesting – large would be more accurate, but I guess Emidio will be pleased that he\’s not expected to dance.
Emidio, how do you feel about being an outspoken murderer?
Promoting Male Voices
Hi, I’m Edward Turner, one of the newer recruits to the choir. I began as a boy soprano and joined Honley Male Voice Choir in my late teens. Sport and studying at Huddersfield Technical College unfortunately forced me to give it up.
As I have a captive audience I want to say few words to all you members and your partners. I was diagnosed with prostate cancer at the age of 55 and would like to make you all aware that it does not just happen to ‘old men’. Any symptoms, however trivial and you really must visit your gp. Early diagnosis is an important factor here and generally a simple blood test can say you definately do not have prostate cancer and even a positive does not necessarily mean that you have it.
I have been fortunate in that I have had excellent treatment both from HRI and Cookridge, though things have kicked in again and hence more treatment. Please, all you do if there is a doubt get checked out, and partners, do nag the men to seek advice.
Prostate cancer is thought by many to be easy to treat and is quite curable. Sadly, I know that is not always the case. I have recently lost my brother-in-law at a young age and he was diagnosed with the same units of cancer in his blood as me. So come on all you men and don’t let it happen to you. The prostate’s not the real problem. It’s the secondary cancer that gets you, if you leave it too late.
Gentlemen, out of nearly 50 men in our choir I am sure there must be others with the problem. Let’s be open about it and encourage as many men as possible to get an early diagnosis.
I’ve recently had to give up my sport because of aches and pains, but I still play tennis twice a week.
(A Cry to Men is also the title of an anonymous 19th century Irish poem, written by a woman, about the dominance of men in everyday life. Now there’s a perspective)
Roderick Williams refers to this podcast as singing for solidarity. Singing with others for joy, to summon communities and to change the world. Roger Scruton tells us that singing with others for a common purpose is a national and european tradition, whether it be in a choir, at a football match or as part of a church service. He goes on to say that our place, from nationhood to where we are personally, is commonly expressed in singing. Identity, where we belong, music and singing all go together.
Professor Stephen Clift talks of singing as a basic part of human nature, common to all of our cultures and all historic periods. It is non-elitist and when in a group takes it to a level of harmony with others that we do not achieve in everyday life.
Oskar Cox Jensen, historian and writer, expanding on the nationhood theme, describes how God Save the King originated as Jacobite support for the pretender, Bonnie Prince Charlie. It disappeared for 70 years and re-emerged as a folksong, popular in the music halls and eventually sung regularly at the end of theatre performances. An adopted National Anthem. It was associated with gang violence in Edinburgh in 1792 when Walter Scott fell out with Irish students and it has a number of different versions, not always complimentary to the monarchy, comparable to football team anthems. Hence music and singing together as expressions of dissent and revolution. Supporters of W. B. Albion agreed that intimidating the opposition was the purpose behind some of their singing.
Anna Redding, during the Women\’s Peace Camp days of Greenham Common, recalls how singing together round the campfire helped them through some of their primitive living conditions and, when they really got going, it was like a collective ecstasy.
The Birmingham Clarion Singers, according to Annie Banham and Jane Scott, began in 1940 when a doctor returned from the Spanish Civil War. Songs of fighting and learning the lessons of the past – the chartists of the 1830s. It is about working class singing – popular protest, a desire for representation.
Workplaces encourage choirs and singing. Alexandria Winn is proud to be part of a Lawyer firm choir in Birmingham. Different floors and departments, not normally known to each other, come together and make a singing community.
In the previous blog we learned about the personal gain of enjoying and being inspired by singing and by the relationships we nurture as a result of the shared interest or passion. Singing is also good for your health and gives you a sense of achievement – clic on link for Chris Rowbury\’s post Reasons for Singing. Today contains examples of why people come together and sing – protest, sense of community, loyalty to place and football team or simply that sense of sharing in something which is much greater than the sum of its parts.
It\’s not for everyone says Stephen Clift – we cannot generalise. Nearly everyone then.
In addition to a personal view from the back row of the baritones, hopefully we are aiming for:
Any of you oldies got an opinion on being Forever Young was a great way to link music, senior singer/songwriters and trying to stay fit into our sixties, seventies and older – Exercise and ageing.
There are millions and millions of words written on this, so I\’m not going to make a significant contribution. Great then that I can quote an authority on the subject, Matt Roberts, writing in The Times, February 18th, 2017, entitled \’How to exercise after 40\’. Can I make a short list?
(1) We need to lift weights because it is quite normal to lose muscle as we age, hence the percent of body fat increases. This keeps up our strength. A bonus is the improvement in bone strength (ladies note).
(2) Get the pulse, breathing and sweating going twice a week to maintain stamina through healthy heart and lungs. The extra here is mental wellbeing.
(3) Pilates. The core, especially abdominals and hips. According to my coach, Ann Little, pilates is the way to tone muscle from the inside out. The spine is a particular beneficiary.
(4) Stretching. Trying to keep suppleness going.
(5) There are other recommendations such as interval training, yoga, lunges and squats, but I have no personal experience of their benefits.
There has to be a number of questions here. How safe is this? Can I start for the first time in my sixties? I have diabetes, angina, parkinsonism and so on; is this for me? Exactly how heavy, how fast, how long, and how often? I\’ve read it somewhere that a good stiff 20 minute walk, five times a week would do it (and golf doesn\’t count).
Well, Matt has some great news. Two or more days off a week and take care over 30 minutes per session. It is sensible/essential to get the okay from your doctor if you worry about your health. She is more likely than not to say \”go for it\”, starting slow with help maybe from your local gym\’s professional trainer. This raises the question of cost – maybe a good investment when your risk of heart and stroke disease falls and you feel better about yourself. Do I follow this advice – yes – I am one of the lucky ones who enjoys exercise for its own sake. See video on Facebook (for some reason it will not load on blogger).
The web is not consistent and some of it is contradictory, so no change there then. The best NHS site for guidelines could be this.
Motivation – getting going and then keeping going. Are there any Tricks about setting goals and freshening them up regularly. Weight loss, a specific challenge (e.g. charity fund-raiser), joining a group and so on. Give yourself a break if you don\’t meet your targets. There are still people who are very athletic and competitive over 70 – let them.
We have a men\’s section in the ladies dominated pilates class down in Holmfirth. It\’s a liberation movement. There\’s arthritis, angina, diabetes, and grumpiness. Then there\’s coffee in Scufflers.
So we\’ve got coffee and exercise. Where are the senior singer/songwriters?
Here\’s one – Knofler
Can the male voice choir survive? – read this telegraph article – it stresses the physical and mental health benefits of singing and social interaction, especially when choir members are working toward a common objective, such as a distinctive sound.
See also reasons for singing previously on this blog
![]() |
| Weekend Scarborough workshop What does beer do that is good for you? |